Top 15 Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oils You Need in Your Kitchen Ranked & Reviewed for 2025
Discover the best organic extra virgin olive oils that elevate your cooking game with rich flavors and health benefits.
La Tourangelle Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$15.72 ($0.93 / Fl Oz)Features:
Cold-pressed from Picual olives, 100% organic, non-GMO, and kosher.
What We Think:
"This vibrant olive oil adds a lovely grassy note to salads and marinades and is perfect for everyday cooking."
Why You'll Love It:
"It’s the perfect kitchen companion—for both novice cooks and culinary artisans. Plus, the quality is unbeatable!"
La Tourangelle Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil Smooth & Fruity
$29.00 ($1.14 / Fl Oz)Features:
Cold-pressed, early harvest olives for a smooth, fruity flavor, sustainably sourced.
What We Think:
"It’s like a gentle hug in a bottle! Smooth enough for drizzling, yet robust enough for cooking."
Why You'll Love It:
"This olive oil makes every meal feel fancy, while being accessible for any home chef."
Atlas Organic Cold Press Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$22.94 ($0.90 / Fl Oz)Features:
Single family farm sourced olives, ethically produced with a complex aroma.
What We Think:
"This oil is a pure delight—its taste is a lovely conversation starter at dinner parties!"
Why You'll Love It:
"With Michelin-starred restaurants trusting it, your kitchen is about to become a gourmet space."
Pompeian Organic Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$7.38 ($0.46 / Fl Oz)Features:
First cold pressed, smooth flavor ideal for sautéing and stir-frying, USDA certified organic.
What We Think:
"This versatile oil is a staple you never knew you needed—great for everything from sautéing veggies to drizzling over bread."
Why You'll Love It:
"It’s affordable and delicious, making healthy cooking super easy."
Bertolli Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$11.99 ($0.47 / Fl Oz)Features:
Rich taste, ideal for dressings, marinades, and pasta dishes, USDA certified organic.
What We Think:
"Bertolli’s been a favorite for centuries for a reason—this oil knows how to elevate simple foods to gourmet dishes!"
Why You'll Love It:
"It’s a go-to that every chef loves to keep in their pantry; versatile for all types of cooking."
Sanniti Laudemio Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$39.97 ($2.35 / Fl Oz)Features:
Gold award winner, USDA organic, gourmet flavor, cold-pressed from hand-picked olives.
What We Think:
"This one is a splurge, but the quality is out of this world. Perfect for special occasions or enhancing a simple meal."
Why You'll Love It:
"“A splash of luxury” is how I’d describe this—ideal for those who truly appreciate gourmet cooking."
California Olive Ranch 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$34.49 ($34.49 / Count)Features:
Crafted exclusively from California olives, versatile for cooking and rich in flavor.
What We Think:
"A true kitchen staple—its buttery, floral profile makes it compatible with just about anything you whip up."
Why You'll Love It:
"Plus, it’s certified non-GMO and vegan, so everyone can enjoy it guilt-free!"
California Olive Ranch California Collection Olive Oil
$23.51 ($23.51 / Count)Features:
100% California extra virgin olive oil, non-GMO, smooth and versatile.
What We Think:
"Great for all types of cooking—from marinating meats to adding flair to your salads. You won’t look back!"
Why You'll Love It:
"This is pure olive oil magic; it keeps freshness in mind with every bottle!"
Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$21.75 ($1.29 / Fl Oz)Features:
Cold-pressed Italian quality, great for a variety of cooking applications and heart-healthy.
What We Think:
"Rich and tasty, it's like Italy has come to your kitchen—perfect for all culinary adventures!"
Why You'll Love It:
"Trust me, your pasta dishes will thank you!"
California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$36.38 ($1.08 / Fl Oz)Features:
Award-winning quality, 100% California olive oil in a convenient 16.9 fl oz bottle.
What We Think:
"Perfect for all your everyday cooking needs—it's lightweight for easy handling."
Why You'll Love It:
"You’ll feel great knowing it’s also eco-friendly and packed with flavor!"
Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$22.77 ($0.67 / Fl Oz)Features:
First cold-pressed with a delicate flavor, certified by the North American Olive Oil Association.
What We Think:
"An everyday staple that will never disappoint in salads, marinades, or just drizzled on fresh bread!"
Why You'll Love It:
"A household name for a reason—this oil never lets you down, it's a must-have!"
Colavita Mediterranean Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$37.85 ($0.56 / Fl Oz)Features:
Italian blend sourced from olives in the Mediterranean, cold-pressed and rich in flavor.
What We Think:
"It’s a win-win for anyone who loves trying new flavors; great for enhancing any meal!"
Why You'll Love It:
"This olive oil is sure to add depth and excitement to your dishes!"
Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$79.53 ($0.78 / Fl Oz)Features:
First cold-pressed, mild flavor, ideal for sautéing and stir-frying.
What We Think:
"This smooth operator is exactly what you need for any quick meal prep that doesn’t compromise taste!"
Why You'll Love It:
"It’s an affordable option that your family will love; great taste without breaking the bank."
Kirkland Signature Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$37.99 ($0.57 / Fl Oz)Features:
67 fl oz, perfect for cooking and dressings, and an unbeatable price point.
What We Think:
"Kirkland delivers high quality for the money, making gourmet cooking accessible for everyone!"
Why You'll Love It:
"Great for bulk buying, you’ll love how versatile it proves to be in the kitchen!"